Phebe Miller married Andrew Carney 3 Oct. 1841 in Vermilion County, IL. There was no other record for Andrew and Phebe Carney.

Found a marriage record in the Indiana Marriages to 1850 for (Mrs.) Phebe Carney to Jonathan Phelps in Vermillion County, Indiana. Marriage date was 11 March 1847.

An 1850 District 21 Vermilion County, Illinois census record was found for Jonathan Phelps age 50 b. Ohio, but no Phebe.